Index

“It is all in the heart”

“It is all in the heart”

Once a poor desert dweller asked for alms from the Muslim ruler Ali. But Ali had nothing at that moment, and he took a handful of sand, read something and blew on the sand clenched in his fist. Then he poured the contents into the Bedouin’s hand, which turned out to be gold.

 

The desert dweller froze in amazement and immediately began to beg the ruler to teach him the prayer by which ordinary sand turned into gold. Ali calmly replied that he had read the Sura Al-Fatiha. The Bedouin, delighted, took the sand in his hands and began to read the first Sura of the Koran and blow on it. But the sand remained sand. The Bedouin asked Ali to explain the wisdom of what had happened. Ali answered briefly, “The whole difference is in the heart.”

I think it would be more correct to call this story a parable, since there is no evidence that it happened in reality. But this is not the important thing: even if we change the characters, the meaning will remain the same. And the meaning is that everything is determined by the state of the heart.

 

The heart determines everything

What do the words “the whole difference is in the heart” mean? Firstly, the literal meaning of this expression comes down to the fact that people have different hearts. And the heart of a Bedouin, who may be immersed in his worldly concerns, cannot compare with the heart of one of the closest companions of the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, a sincere Muslim, an insightful person and a brave warrior who was promised Paradise during his lifetime. Secondly, the “difference” in the heart implies a difference in intention. The intention of the Bedouin was to receive alms, while the intention of the Caliph Ali was to give alms, relying entirely on the power of the Creator.

 

The heart is changeable

However, one should not expect that a person is gifted with a heart pure from vices forever. The word “heart” itself is translated from Arabic as “fickle” or “turning over”. The Messenger of God ﷺ said, “The heart takes its name from its constant changes. The likeness of the heart is a feather at the root of a tree, repeatedly turned over by the wind.” (Narrated by Ahmad).

We are surprised to observe changes in the character and behavior of others but we do not think that we ourselves risk ending up in their place. Consistency in following the truth (istikamat) is a trait of the chosen righteous, while even the best of people were afraid to stray from the right path, realizing the fickle nature of the heart. It is no coincidence that the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ often turned to the Almighty with a prayer: “O Changer of the hearts, make my heart firm upon Your religion.”

 

To be continued…

 

Malika Voronina

As-Salam writer

2026-05-01 (Dhul-Qaida 1447) №5.


Ali ibn al-Husayn ibn Ali (Zayn al-‘Abidin)

“I have never seen a Quraysh better than Ali ibn al-Husayn.” (az-Zuhri).   In a special year, the final page in the history of the Persian kings was turned. Yazdegerd, the last Persian king, died homeless and persecuted. His generals, guards and members of his family were...


The Ideal Husband’s Commandments

Family is a daily effort. And for any family to be successful, both spouses must work hard, for, as the saying goes, one man is no match for another. To be happy in marriage, a woman does not need much... Although it is not... In fact, she needs much... But in this article, we will limit ourselves...


The Hidden Power of Good Character: What is Righteousness in Islam?

Good moral character is one of the most revered qualities in Islam. Allah, the Almighty, has commanded people to ennoble their character, along with performing the five daily prayers, fasting during Ramadan, paying zakat, performing pilgrimage and fulfilling other religious...


Escape from silence

Why when we alone, we immediately reach for our phones, turn on a series, or other stuff, or do anything to avoid encountering our own thoughts? What are we so afraid of hearing in that silence, and how can we learn to bear it in order to finally hear our true selves?   This is not just a...


Water Wheels of Syria

I have a 1978 Syrian Republic banknote in my collection, worth one Syrian pound, depicting two enormous water wheels. They are located near the city of Hama in central Syria and to this day, anyone can see the operation of this amazing ancient structure – enormous twin wooden wheels located on the...